Header Logo
Transform With Tab Meet Tab Educator Resources The Inside-Out Newsletter Contact Blog Book a FREE Strategy Call
← Back to all posts

The Unspoken Hierarchy: Why Principals Still Feel Like Outsiders in Leadership Clusters

by Tabitha Leonard
Jul 13, 2025
Connect

 

HAPPY Sunday, Achiever! 🙌

You're a principal. You’ve earned the title. But every time you enter a cluster meeting, there's a quiet undercurrent that says, “You’re not quite in.”


Seniority. Decile. School size. Advisory board seats. These aren’t on the agenda—but they are the real conversation.


This is social comparison theory in action.
It’s why some speak freely while others shrink back.
Why ideas from one voice are praised while another is politely ignored.

 

And it’s not just about belonging—it’s about psychological safety. Without it, even the best strategies fail. The smartest plans stall. And good leaders—like you—begin to second-guess themselves.

 

We’re often taught that proving our competence, performing flawlessly, and perfecting every detail will earn us a seat at the table—that social significance and positional relevance are won through results and relentless effort. But what if that’s not what truly builds connection and trust in leadership circles?

 

What if your strategic genius isn’t the problem… but the silent tension in the room is?

 

When Strategy Fails—And Silence Speaks Louder Than Success

 

I worked with a principal—let’s call her Megan—who had spent months refining her new initiative. She had the data, the vision, and the plan. Her strategy was solid.

But during the cluster meeting, she presented it… and was met with polite nods. No one challenged it. No one offered feedback. And no one supported it.

Later, another principal shared a nearly identical idea—and received instant enthusiasm. Megan was left wondering, “Why didn’t mine land the same way?”

This wasn’t about the idea. It was about the room. Unspoken hierarchies were at play. Psychological safety was missing. Social comparison silenced contribution.

 

Self-Acceptance vs Social Comparison:

What’s Really Driving Disconnection?

Subscribe to keep reading this post

Subscribe

Already have an account? Log in

Loading...
From Self-Sacrifice to Sustainable Strength
  HAPPY Sunday, Achiever!   What if putting everyone else first isn’t leadership—it’s a slow form of self-erasure?   We’re taught that great leaders give their all. But what happens when “giving your all” leaves you with nothing left? Marie—a school principal deeply committed to her team and family—didn’t come to coaching because she lacked skill or drive. She came because she was quietly run...
From Overidentifying to Empowered, Intentional Leadership
  HAPPY Sunday, Achiever!   How Mike Reclaimed His Energy, Boundaries, and Impact   1. Challenging the Common Belief Leadership isn’t about carrying it all. Many high-performing leaders believe that being “good” means being available, approachable, and ready to solve everyone else’s problems. But what if that belief is quietly draining your energy, dulling your impact, and costing your team t...
From Overextended Leader to Calm, Confident Catalyst
  HAPPY Sunday, Achiever!   Most leaders think the key to being effective is being available.But the truth? Always being available makes you less impactful. When you’re stretched too thin, constantly reacting, and over-functioning to keep the wheels turning—you might look like a strong leader… But inside, you’re tired, resentful, and slowly losing connection to the very purpose that got you h...

The Inside-Out Newsletter

The Inside-Out Newsletter is for mission-driven leaders who are brilliant at their work—but now find themselves stretched, second-guessing, or navigating the weight of leading others. Each week, you’ll receive high-impact insights, practical tools, and powerful mindset shifts rooted in the Inside-Out Leadership System™—designed to help you lead with clarity, confidence, and calm, even in the chaos. This isn’t just another leadership tip sheet. It’s your space to pause, reflect, and realign with the habits and presence that create true influence—from the inside out. Whether you’re managing team dynamics, adapting to rapid change, or simply craving more energy and meaning in your role, this newsletter helps you reconnect with your purpose, sharpen your focus, and lead with intention. Think of it as your weekly reset—your reminder that leadership doesn’t have to cost you your energy or identity.
Footer Logo
© 2025 TABITHA LEONARD NZ. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Join The FREE Challenge

Enter your details below to join the challenge.