Safety Before Strategy - The Missing Ingredient in High-Performance Conversations
May 24, 2025
We often assume that strategy is the key to success.
If we plan well, map out the objectives, set clear KPIs, and hold regular meetings, we’ll drive results. Right?
Not always.
We forget that even the most brilliant strategy will collapse under the weight of silence.
If your team isn’t speaking up, challenging ideas, or offering perspectives from the front lines—you don’t have a strategy problem.
You have a safety problem.
A senior leader I worked with had everything mapped out to the letter.
The vision was compelling.
The roadmap was detailed.
The resources were lined up.
From the outside, it looked like a masterclass in strategic planning.
But inside the room?
Tension. Hesitation. And the sound of polite agreement—disguising deeper concerns no one felt safe enough to raise. 😟
Every meeting felt like dragging a dead weight uphill. Decisions were made, but execution was slow.
Feedback loops were thin. Momentum stalled.
It wasn’t until we shifted our focus from strategy to safety that things began to change.
We pressed pause on deliverables and leaned into deeper dialogue:
- What are you really thinking—but hesitating to say?
- Where are we missing the mark?
- What would make it safer to speak up in this space?
At first, there was discomfort.
But then, something powerful happened: people started telling the truth.
Not in a hostile or defensive way—but with honesty, care, and courage.
They named blind spots in the plan.
They shared insights from the field.
They offered better ideas.
And that’s when everything shifted.
The strategy didn’t need to be redrafted.
It needed to be co-owned. People Support What They Create!
Once the emotional safety net was in place, ideas flowed, momentum built, and the initiative finally gained traction.
That’s when the leader looked at me and said something I’ll never forget:
“It wasn’t the plan that was broken. It was the conversation.”
Safety isn’t a fluffy ‘nice to have.’ It’s a strategic lever.
In high-performance environments, trust and psychological safety aren’t nice-to-haves—they’re the invisible foundations that everything else rests on.
They are the quiet forces that determine whether your team performs, innovates, or simply complies.
They shape whether conversations lead to progress or politeness… whether meetings unlock brilliance or bury it.
When people feel safe—emotionally, psychologically, and interpersonally—they bring their full selves to the table.
They take risks. They offer bold ideas. They challenge assumptions and contribute meaningfully.
They speak up not because they’re fearless—but because they know they won’t be punished for being honest, different, or wrong.
But when safety is missing—even subtly—self-protection kicks in.
People start filtering.
They scan for approval instead of offering insight.
They say what they think you want to hear, not what you need to hear.
They play small, stay quiet, and second-guess themselves—because the cost of vulnerability feels too high.
The irony?
Without safety, we don’t get high performance—we get high politeness.
And high politeness doesn’t lead to growth. It leads to stagnation, missed opportunities, and a whole lot of unspoken brilliance left on the table.
Safety is not the enemy of high standards.
It’s how we reach them—without silencing the very voices we need to get there.
Think of it this way:
- High strategy + low safety = resistance, silence, mediocrity
- Medium strategy + high safety = engagement, innovation, momentum
🔄 From Command to Connection
Three Micro Shifts to Move from Strategy-First to Safety-First Conversations
Small shifts. Big results.
Here’s how to create the kind of conversations that drive both trust and traction.
1️⃣ Shift from Advising to Inquiring
Ask before you tell.
When we lead with advice, we unintentionally position ourselves as the expert and others as passive recipients. While our intentions might be helpful, the impact can stifle ownership and shut down innovation.
Inquiry flips that script.
Instead of:
“Here’s what I think we should do…”
Try:
“What’s your perspective on this?”
“What have you noticed that we might be missing?”
This subtle shift says, “Your view matters.”
It invites co-creation, and more importantly, it gives people permission to show up—not just to perform, but to participate with purpose.
2️⃣ Shift from Appraising to Inviting
Replace judgment with curiosity.
Appraising statements like “That’s not what we agreed on” or “That’s not quite right” may seem like efficient course-correctors, but they often create defensiveness and withdrawal.
When someone feels judged, their brain shifts into protection mode—meaning learning, listening, and creativity take a back seat.
Instead, extend an invitation into deeper thinking.
Try:
“Can you walk me through your thinking here?”
“Help me understand how you came to that conclusion.”
This moves the conversation from correction to connection.
It signals, “You’re safe here. I want to understand you, not fix you.”
And when people feel understood, they’re more willing to listen, adapt, and grow.
3️⃣ Shift from Strategy-First to Safety-First
Start with how people feel, not what they need to do.
We often jump straight to action plans, forgetting that the emotional landscape of the room is the terrain strategy has to travel through.
Without safety, even the most brilliant plans meet quiet resistance. With safety, even an imperfect plan can spark commitment.
Try opening with:
“What would make this feel like a safe space to share ideas today?”
“What do you need from me in this conversation to feel supported?”
This isn’t about lowering standards—it’s about raising trust.
It shows that your leadership isn’t just about direction, but about connection.
And that’s what transforms strategy from a static document into shared momentum
🔍 Reflective Prompts:
Take 5 minutes to ask yourself:
-
What does psychological safety look like and sound like in my leadership style?
-
When was the last time someone challenged your idea—and you made it safe to do so?
-
Do people leave your conversations feeling seen, heard, and energised?
Safety isn’t the enemy of high standards.
It’s how we actually uphold them—without burning people out or shutting them down. When people feel safe, they speak up, lean in, and go further.
Not because they have to, but because they want to. It’s not about lowering expectations—it’s about creating the kind of environment where people feel confident bringing their best ideas to the table.
And let’s be honest, if we want our strategy to land, we need our people to feel safe enough to be real, to challenge, and to contribute fully.
That’s where real performance comes from—not pressure, but trust.
Find me on LinkedIn
Or Book a 1:1 Discovery Call